Should Affirmative Action exist?

  
Asked in Society by a contributor
edited by Instigator

Yes
or
No
1 Yes Take
Write Your Yes Take
0 like 0 dislike
In the US, affirmative action policies should exist but only in a limited capacity. Use them as a means for admissions or HR personnel to understand an applicant's accomplishments in light of any obstacles or challenges they may have faced due to their race or sex. Things like race or gender should only be considered if they can be definitively shown by the applicant to have been a clear disadvantage at some point in their lives, compared to applicants who didn't face similar extenuating circumstances. Right now they're applied way too liberally.
1 No Take
Write Your No Take
0 like 0 dislike

It's not needed and it's totally outdated. It just gives special treatment to people who don't need it anymore. It promotes racism and undermines the idea that race doesn't matter when you're deciding if an applicant is qualified. It's ridiculous that it wasn't abolished decades ago!

Written by a contributor

Related Write Fights

1 take
Asked in Society by Tmwm2
Police and law enforcement shouldn't profile. It seems like there are …
3 takes
Asked in Society by a contributor
Yes, a man who gives birth to a child should get paternity leave just …
3 takes
2 takes
Asked in Economics by Instigator
Built-in gratuities work best for corporate clients. Execs don't have …
2 takes
Asked in Philosophy by a contributor
Absolutely not. I've never taken philosophy and it hasn't harmed me. I…